Mangler Lure 4'' Swimbait Review
I’m always on the lookout for good alternatives to more expensive lures. One that recently caught my eye was the Mangler 4’’ swimbait, available for just $2.75. For fans of smaller swimbaits, it should be apparent that the Mangler 4’’ swimbait is very similar to incredibly popular Megabait Charlieswimbait (ICAST Best New Lure Winner and reviewed at Tackle Tour). I noticed this immediately and this was one of the main reasons I was interested in this lure. I’ve caught a lot of quality largemouth bass on the Megabait Charlie, including some very hefty fish and I curious to see if the Mangler’s version would be a viable alternative.
 |
| See that swimbait in the mouth? This is a 5lb largemouth I caught on the Megabait Charlie swimbait |
Mangler 4'' Swimbait Action
Design
Recently, when fishing at Lake Elsinore in California, I was trying out the Mangler 4’’ swimbaits. My friend was fishing nearby and remarked on just how lifelike these Mangler lures looked; it was his first time seeing this lure and he was quite impressed. The obvious differences in this lure from the MegabaitCharlie in design stem from the different metal used for the line tie on the front of the Manger version, it’s much thinner and lightweight than the Megabait Charlie line tie. I’m not sure if the thinner metal may pose a threat to lighter line or not, but it’s certainly something to be aware of. The Megabait Charlie comes in 4 different sizes, including a 4’’, but the Mangler version only comes in the 4’’ size. That’s fine with me, as the 4’’ version was the one I primarily used anyway. Internal rattles sound the same and the front lip is pretty close in thickness.
While I was impressed with how closely the Mangler version resembled the Megabait swimbaits, I was not too pleased with the color selection available for the Mangler swimbait. Many of the colors available are quite garish and not quite as realistic as I would like. One of the strong benefits of the Megabait Charlie line was the solid selection of colors. However, the Mangler version does come with several decent lure patterns, my favorite being the red/black and the all black swimbaits. These were the ones that I caught fish on and they looked fantastic swimming in the water.
Recently, when fishing at Lake Elsinore in California, I was trying out the Mangler 4’’ swimbaits. My friend was fishing nearby and remarked on just how lifelike these Mangler lures looked; it was his first time seeing this lure and he was quite impressed. The obvious differences in this lure from the MegabaitCharlie in design stem from the different metal used for the line tie on the front of the Manger version, it’s much thinner and lightweight than the Megabait Charlie line tie. I’m not sure if the thinner metal may pose a threat to lighter line or not, but it’s certainly something to be aware of. The Megabait Charlie comes in 4 different sizes, including a 4’’, but the Mangler version only comes in the 4’’ size. That’s fine with me, as the 4’’ version was the one I primarily used anyway. Internal rattles sound the same and the front lip is pretty close in thickness.
While I was impressed with how closely the Mangler version resembled the Megabait swimbaits, I was not too pleased with the color selection available for the Mangler swimbait. Many of the colors available are quite garish and not quite as realistic as I would like. One of the strong benefits of the Megabait Charlie line was the solid selection of colors. However, the Mangler version does come with several decent lure patterns, my favorite being the red/black and the all black swimbaits. These were the ones that I caught fish on and they looked fantastic swimming in the water.
Action
In a direct comparison to the Megabait Charlie swimbaits, the Mangler 4’’swimbaits looked almost identical in the water. Swimming action was the classic side to side wobble that I’ve come to expect from these and they felt almost exactly the same on retrieve. I was definitely impressed by this! The Mangler 4’’ lures seemed a tad bit stiffer, but not by much. Bass readily chased them down, even after seeing the lure a few times. It slowly sinks in the water, so you have plenty of opportunity to retrieve-pause-retrieve without too much of a change in lure depth. I had several videos of this lure in action in an urban creek and at Fairmount Park; unfortunately I lost them when my hard drive crashed. Instead, take a look at the Mangler's official lure video (posted above), with great underwater action shots.
Durability
The Mangler swimbaits were a mixed bag when it came to standing up to repeated use. I was able to catch and land largemouth bass on these swimbaits without any noticeable problems or damage to the lures, even with the stock hooks. However, after prolonged use over several fishing trips, I noticed the front line tie and nose of the swimbait would crack or bend upwards. This was not a problem I ever encountered with the more expensive Megabait Charlie lures. I definitely wouldn’t suggest relying on these for large bass or other fish. They seemed to be more appropriate for the smaller bass found in the urban SoCal creeks that I frequent.
Price
It’s hard to beat the price on these Mangler swimbaits. At $2.75 each, they are a far more affordable option than the Megabait Charlie swimbaits. The super low price of these swimbaits is definitely one of their strongest suits. You’ll notice in the video I posted that I am fishing near some pretty heavy and gross (typical urban creek) cover. I usually wouldn’t throw a swimbait in this muck, but I’m not as worried about losing a $2.75 lure as opposed to a $15 Japanese swimbait. The Mangler lure website also sells a lot of other super affordable lures for both warmwater and coldwater species, including some very nicely priced micro crankbaits, jerkbaits and topwater poppers. Mangler also offers a unique in-line spinner, reviewed positively by Tackle Tour and featured all over YouTube.
Summary
In short, the Mangler 4’’ swimbaits look great in the water, catch fish and are incredibly affordable. The lower cost doesn’t come without a price, as certain components are noticeably lower in quality. I wouldn’t suggest depending on their durability for very large fish, but for smaller bass they held up decently. I currently have several of these in my tackle box alongside their Megabait Charlie cousins, perfect for tossing in urban creeks for largemouth bass.
San Dimas Reservoir Fishing Exploration Video
San Dimas Reservoir, in the Los Angeles National Forest, is in the hills above San Dimas, California. It's a fairly small reservoir, when compared to the nearby San Gabriel, Morris and Big Dalton reservoirs (only one of those is open for fishing, sadly). This region was hit pretty hard by the Williams Fire, several years back. I've heard the fire resulted in a lot of soot and other debris being deposited in San Dimas Reservoir, and that, along with recent draining and dredging, supposedly killed the most of the fishery that previously existed. Reports from local fishing websites described trout, bass, sunfish and catfish being caught at San Dimas Reservoir prior to that fire, but I hadn't seen any new reports in a long time. Still, the reservoir is listed as open for fishing online and that was enough for me to go check it out.(More on the legal status of fishing at this reservoir below).
I was able to shoot some footage while overlooking the reservoir and you can watch it on YouTube here. As you can see from the video, the lake is pretty far down a steep cliff from the main public road. The only paved path down to the lake is fenced off. Supposedly, this used to be popular way to access the lake and it used to be ok for the public to use it. You will also notice that there is not any signs forbidding fishing or hiking along the shore of the reservoir, it's just boating, swimming and wading that is prohibited.
Unfortunately, accessing the shore is not easy. If you don't want to scale the cliff from the road, you'll have to drive down the end of San Dimas Canyon road, park near the fire station and hike in from the north side of the reservoir, along the creek, not a short treck. There is also no maintained public access in this area, but there are some rough hiking trails that I spotted on this side of the reservoir.
Now, for the really interesting part. I did a LOT of calling around and inquiring about the actual status of fishingat San Dimas Reservoir. I initially spoke with the Angeles National Forest rangers; they told me the following:
1. They are not aware of any restrictions on hiking or fishing in that area, aside from the off-limits experimental forest at the far north end of San Dimas Canyon Road.
2. While the Angeles National Forest rangers oversee the area of San Dimas Reservoir, the actual reservoir falls under the operation of the Los Angeles Flood Control people.
Thus, I ended up contacting the previously-mentioned department. Annoyingly, they first told me:
"The reservoir is not open to the public. Additionally, the reservoir is not stocked with fish and is routinely drained on an annual basis. The side slopes between the reservoir and San Dimas Canyon Road are very steep and can be dangerous. Please note that there are two trail heads used by hikers on the easterly side of the San Dimas Canyon Road which lead away from the reservoir area and up into the easterly hills. Thank you for the inquiry."
However, after replying to their email asking for further information, I received the following:
"My apology for the confusion. Los Angeles County Code indeed states that fishing is allowed at San Dimas Reservoir (unless signs are posted to indicate otherwise). For the current status of San Dimas Reservoir, Department of Fish and Game has stopped stocking fish in the reservoir for at least the past three years due to our maintenance activities at the facility which require the draining of the reservoir. In 2008 & 2009, accumulated sediment in the reservoir were removed. Two maintenance projects at the dam followed which require continuous draining of the reservoir. The first one has been completed and we anticipate the 2nd maintenance project to start by summer and finish by the end of this year. The hiking trails outside the reservoir area is under the jurisdiction of the US Forest Service."
If anyone is interested, I believe the actual county code they are referring to is "20.92.030 Fishing restrictions"
"A person shall not fish in the waters of any reservoir, debris basin or spreading grounds owned by or under the control of the Los Angeles County Flood Control District, except that fishing will be permitted from the banks of Puddingstone Reservoir, San Dimas Reservoir, San Gabriel No. 1 Reservoir, and Cogswell Reservoir (unless such reservoirs are posted to the contrary by signs plainly visible from the banks thereof), and from boats on Puddingstone Reservoir, San Dimas Reservoir, Big Tujunga Reservoir, San Gabriel No. 1 Reservoir and Cogswell Reservoir by persons having valid boat permits under Section 20.92.020 of this chapter, all within the regularly designated fishing season as established by the California State Fish and Game Commission, or by other competent authority, and in compliance with the terms and conditions and during the hours specified in the boat permit hereinabove referred to. (Ord. 10280 § 1, 1971: Ord. 4700 § 3, 1946.)"
Finally, I found a pretty fascinating document showing the Los Angeles Public Works department request to do further maintenance on the dam and reservoir. The actual document is very large (be warned), but for those interested it contains a wealth of information on the fish species observed at this reservoir and below it, future plans for development and more. It's definitely worth looking through, even if you have just a passing interesting in San Dimas Reservoir. Here is the direct link to the .PDF for the whole project.
Now, there is a tiny creek (San Dimas Creek?) that supplies the reservoir. It does appear to have a few very small fish, but has very limited places to fish from and the water is quite fast.
Overall, San Dimas Reservoir looks like a very interesting and relatively secluded lake with very little fishing pressure. I'm still not clear about what fish may remain in this little lake, given the draining and development, but I would like to return sometime soon for further exploration of this mountain reservoir.
Mackerel Attack!
I usually go fishing for freshwater species. However, at times I'll get to fish the mighty Pacific Ocean, usually from various piers and jetties scattered across the coast. Laguna, Dana Point, Newport and so on-all offer some fun fishing opportunities for a wide variety of species. I'm still working on improving my lure skills in saltwater; I usually do better with cut pieces of shrimp, but I have manged a few nice catches on jigs.
Recently went out to one of my favorite jetties and had a ball catching mackerel all afternoon. To be honest, the mack bite wasn't as wild as it sometimes is, but it was still fun. I and my friend managed to land close to 20 mackerel in a few hours. We kept the largest 4; they are quite tasty if prepared correctly. It was really fun to watch the pelicans crash into the surf, as they divebombed schools of macks and other fish.
Recently went out to one of my favorite jetties and had a ball catching mackerel all afternoon. To be honest, the mack bite wasn't as wild as it sometimes is, but it was still fun. I and my friend managed to land close to 20 mackerel in a few hours. We kept the largest 4; they are quite tasty if prepared correctly. It was really fun to watch the pelicans crash into the surf, as they divebombed schools of macks and other fish.
